Ineos Grenadier vs Defender: “Hammers all end up looking very alike”

Sure, the Ineos Grenadier looks a lot like an iconic British off-roader we all know well, but that wasn’t the aim.

Starting a car company from scratch is a rare opportunity – something few in the automotive industry ever get the chance to do in their careers.

So it was no surprise that the guys behind Ineos Automotive were as excited to show me the new Grenadier as I was to see. For the record, I think it’s a great piece of industrial design. Pretty? No. Familiar? Very.

I’ve done extremely well to make it to just the third paragraph here without mentioning the original Land Rover Defender, because that’s the car that has clearly inspired the Grenadier more than any other. And it’s the car that its design will be most compared to.

Is that a bad thing? Well, Land Rover tried and failed to trademark the Defender shape, and it’s clear that there’s still a huge passion for the old Defender among enthusiasts. Whether those enthusiasts turn into Grenadier customers remains to be seen, though.

What struck me having spent time with the team behind the Grenadier, however, is the clarity of purpose. They referenced the Willys Jeep and how that car was designed by numbers; the US military decided what they wanted the car to do, and engineers did just that.

The same approach has been taken with the Grenadier. They decided what they wanted the car to be able to achieve, and built a car around that.

“There’s nothing fluffy or extraneous,” designer Toby Ecuyer told me.

And if you’re going to design a car to do a specific thing, then maybe the original way is still the best way. As Ecuyer explained:

“If you’re designing a hammer, it has to perform a certain function. And, pretty much, hammers all end up looking very alike.” Fair enough.

I’m impressed by much of the original thinking from Ineos so far – even if the styling is far from original. More than anything, I’m impressed by how the firm has listened to potential owners – giving it a much better chance of success.

Steve Fowler

Pierre Gasly’s shock win, Williams and Renault to Alpine

If F1 is to remain the pinnacle of single seat racing, it needs other ways to stay competitive

How green are electric cars?

Electric car maker reveals whole-life CO2 emissions of the Polestar 2 are better than a petrol XC40 - but EV is only 14% cleaner with global energy mix

Toyota GR Super Sport hypercar makes public debut at Le Mans

First public outing for Japanese firm's new halo car, which is being developed in road-going and racing forms ahead of 2021 launch

Related articles